Friday, November 6, 2009

A philosophy of life


The New York Times ran a review of one of the new Ayn Rand biographies last week, and just like that, Bam! I was back in high school.

I had two best friends in eleventh grade--Kay and Carla. They were both stunningly beautiful--one had shimmering blond hip-length hair and huge blue eyes, and the other had shimmering dark brown hip-length hair and huge dark eyes. They were intelligent and highly intellectual and I felt awed and honored that they included me in their sophisticated conversations about Nietzsche (who I frantically tried to understand) and religion.

And then one day they started talking about someone named Ayn Rand. Rand wrote books that had titles like "The Virtue of Selfishness" and "Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal," so that gives you a good idea of her outlook on life.

She also wrote big thick potboiler novels that set her philosophy into motion. "The Fountainhead" and "Atlas Shrugged" were about what she called the "heroes"--fabulously gorgeous, brilliant men and women who lived on a higher plane than the rest of us, who worked passionately only to fulfill their own dreams and make themselves happy. Rand believed that selfishness, applied this way, was what would keep the world progressing--that man works hardest and most honestly when he works for himself, and himself alone. There was no room in her philosophy for empathy or compassion, and no room among the heroes for the weak, the aging, the infirm, or, really, the friendly. (Those people she called "the looters.")

Kay and Carla were deeply influenced by her books. If you look at Rand's life, you can understand her abhorrence for anything done for the collective good--she grew up in Russia and was a young teen during the Bolshevik Revolution. Her father's thriving business was taken over by the state and she and her family were forced from their home and into a small apartment that they shared with strangers.

It must have been awful. So I can understand her viewpoint. But for happy, healthy 16-year-old girls from Duluth? To embrace wholeheartedly such a cold philosophy? A little harder to see. Except for the fact that Rand's books were so romantic; it was easy to get swept away with the beauty and riches and superiority and sex sex sex of the incredibly perfect main characters.

Kay and Carla allowed me to listen to their talks about Rand for some time before they solemnly handed over one of her books. I knew this was a test: I was to read "Atlas Shrugged" and report back to them. This was unnerving. I knew my fate was on the line, and I worried I would not measure up.

"Atlas Shrugged" is about the day when all of the heroes of the world go on strike, and the world, left to the inferior looters, grinds to a halt. It is a very long book, and if it weren't for the fabulously steamy sex scenes that livened it up for my innocent 16-year-old eyes, I might not have made it through. Rand wanted to make sure that readers understood her philosophy, and so she hammered it, over and over and over, and just when you wanted to scream "I get it! It's not that complicated!" she stops all action for fifty pages and allows the main character to give a speech that sets it all out again.

I finished the book and wondered what I would tell my friends. Iwondered if they would still be my friends once we had had the talk.

Kay invited me to her house on a Saturday afternoon. Carla was there, too. They sat on the patio in deck chairs, their long glossy hair gleaming in the sun. I scratched my poodle head and shoved my glasses back up my nose. (Of course neither of them wore glasses; heroes, apparently, have 20-20 vision.)

They asked my assessment and then coolly watched and waited while I sweated.

I stumbled out a few things about how brilliant it was and how great it was and what a fabulous read, but, um, it was a bit long, wasn't it, and somewhat repetitive?

Kay and Carla glanced at each other and I was filled with dread; I knew I was doomed.

There were a few ominous moments of silence, and then Kay spoke. "I didn't think there was a superfluous word in the entire book," she said. She and Carla got up and walked into the house and shut the door.

And that was it. Friendless.

31 comments:

The Green Stone Woman said...

Oh, how awful, but at least you could then make up your own mind about what you thought of it and choose your own philosophy of life. At least you voted for the right people. And chose your own better friends. Those two little girls were doomed from the start.

Rudee said...

More importantly, I would like a where are they now update. We know where you stand. Consider yourself blessed for having escaped that test with your integrity.

The Frontline special I watched last week explored Alan Greenspan's belief in Rand's philosophy. Too bad he couldn't take his blinders off while he had the opportunity, but like your so called friends, he was enthralled. I can't imagine, but maybe it was the sex that did it.

Kim said...

Ah, Laurie. We'd have been tight, you and me. I hate Ayn Rand.

Stupid girls with their stupid long and straight hair. Give me your gorgeous curls any day.

T. Clear said...

Good for you for your honesty!

Tiki (& sometimes Kesey) said...

A dog would never do that to you.

Kesey

laurie said...

rudee, in one of her books--perhaps it was her play, "night of january 16th"--the heroine has a gown made of lacy platinum. they heat it up and she puts it on and her body shimmers under the metal and the metal burns her skin and the hero kisses her wherever it's burned....

oh rand and sex, man. she should have added a Y to her last name.

Rudee said...

Bwahahahaha. I just snorted my coffee. Ayn Randy, indeed!

MJ Krech said...

Oooh-Boy, can I relate to this story! I had more than one similar experience. Parents moved us to the snooty part of town for the better high school and then I had to endure the "beautiful people" for six long years. Yikes! You've hit the spot with this story! Spot-on, Laurie!

laurie said...

oh, and rudee--i have no idea where they are now. i pretty much didn't see them again after that afternoon.

Queenmothermamaw said...

That book fascinated me. That does not mean I agree with her philosophy, but the book was something else. I read it twice. The last governor of Kentucky was said to have 2 books in his library. The Bible and Atlas Shrugged. Guess he needed polar resources.
QMM

tiogatime said...

HAAA!!! too funny. another great story!

thanks, laurie, for making the choice to hang out with the imperfect, self-deprecating, funny people of the world!!

Pamela M. Miller said...

My best friend in high school and I used to endlessly debate "The Brothers Karamazov," but we scorned Ayn Rand. Actually I never knew anything about her. Interesting entry. And no wonder you don't want to go to your high school class reunion! You might encounter those cold girls! :)

elizabethm said...

The first time I came across her I was in my early twenties and I thought the philosophy flawed and the novels turgid. Seen no reason to change my mind. I wonder if you erstwhile friends have changed theirs as they grew older?

Green Girl in Wisconsin said...

I think your perceptiveness was developed at a very young age. I hate Ayn Rand, too. EW.

patty said...

i'll add their names to my list of people who think they are better than anyone else. when i was 16 i thought i knew it all too, but i don't think i was ever unkind, more like the other way around. took me years to decide that i didn't care about what other people thought of me

Gail said...

...and you survived without them. If you can't voice your opinions to your friends, than they are not friends.

I am sorry you had to find out the way you did. Sometimes the self sung heroes are just plain snooty.

Benny and Lily said...

ugh...snooty we say...Ayn Rand
Benny & Lily

Sandy said...

You were friendless before that conversation started. You just didn't know it. What creeps!

willowtree said...

Don't worry about it, I bet they're both fat and smelly now, with a dozen kids each and functional haircuts.

Babaloo said...

I've never read Ayn Rand and I don't think I'm going to either.

Pity you had to find out about these two "ladies" the way you did but I guess you knew anyway, they weren't friend material anyway. Because friends do have compassion and regard for others.

DC said...

Just discovered your blog and read your Ayn Rand post. Ouch, sweetie.
And good for you for speaking your truth.

Amy said...

You seem to have done all right without them. I don't really trust anyone who finds meaning and inspiration from Ayn Rand's books.

Regarding your Halloween story, things must be different in the big city than they are around here.

Far Side of Fifty said...

It is just as well that you left those girls in the dust, long straight hair and all:)

SmitoniusAndSonata said...

How ill-mannered of them . And infantile .
Do you think they ever managed to become "heroes" themselves or just became decreasingly shimmering trophy wives for some busy "hero"?
You , on the other hand , were clever enough to see the real world beyond , with all its richness and colour , and went off and found it .

jan said...

I've thought about the comment I would like to make about Ayn Rand's philosophy. I'm sure I will displease many. I have just reread "Atlas Shrugged" and I have read most of her other books. I agree her books are long and repetitive. The point I think she was trying to make, is that a person has the right to their physical and intellectual property. When this is taken away, where is the incentive to produce?

I doubt the sixteen year old girls saw beyond the perceived approval of selfishness.

Will now duck and wait for the criticism to come my way.

Jim said...

Hopefully they grew out of that phase and developed some compassion for other human beings. And if they didn't, well, it's good that you parted ways with them, even if it was painful at the time.

laurie said...

jan, people might disagree with you but they won't flame you, not here on this blog.

i agree with you that people have a right to their intellectual property; and i also agree that people work hardest when the motivation comes from within.

where ayn rand and i part ways, though, is in her utter lack of compassion for people who don't have the skills or intelligence or luck or circumstances to succeed.

she thinks it's wrong to help people; i think it's wrong not to.

Bill Hicks said...

And thus it was that you embarked on a life in reality, and I expect your many friends are the better for it. Bravo.

Pamela said...

Rand was kind of like a compass -
She gets you going a direction you think will get you to the highest point (north pole)
... but doesn't.

(speaking of magnetic north - I keep hearing that its out in the Aleutian Islands somewhere and still moving)

Kate said...

Who needs those kinds of friends?! You were dead right!

Indigo Bunting said...

What a story! Is this how you got into book reviews?